Despite receiving mixed reviews from critics, NBC has officially renewed its serial killer drama “The Hunting Party” for a second season, much to the surprise of fans who had been anxiously awaiting news about the show’s future. The announcement came on May 12, 2025, as reported by Variety, shortly after the conclusion of the show’s freshman run that began on January 19 of the same year.
The thriller, which follows a team of investigators tracking down escaped serial killers after a devastating explosion at a high-tech prison, has struggled to win over critics since its debut. Many reviewers have pointed out the show’s similarities to other serial killer dramas like “Hannibal,” suggesting a lack of originality in its premise.
Nevertheless, NBC appears to be doubling down on its investment, banking on the audience engagement rather than critical acclaim.
Created by showrunners JJ Bailey and Jake Coburn, “The Hunting Party” features an ensemble cast led by Melissa Roxburgh, with Nick Wechsler, Patrick Sabongui, Josh McKenzie, and Sara Garcia rounding out the team of profilers, soldiers, spies, and special agents. The distinctive approach of hunting different killers each episode has become a defining characteristic of the series.
The show’s episodic structure, which dedicates each installment to pursuing a different killer, has apparently clicked with viewers despite the critical reception. With an average of 4.2 million total viewers including delayed playback, the show has performed well enough to secure its future. Following the trend of hybrid distribution models, the series maximizes its reach through both traditional broadcasting and streaming platforms.
The series, produced by Universal Television, airs weekly on NBC with episodes available for streaming on Peacock the following day. This distribution strategy may have contributed to the show’s renewal, offering multiple avenues for audience discovery and engagement.
Details about the sophomore season remain scarce, with no information yet released about potential plot developments, new characters, or an expected air date.
The renewal decision suggests NBC sees untapped potential in the series’ high-concept premise and is willing to give the creative team another shot at refining their vision. For fans who’ve become invested in the cat-and-mouse game between hunters and killers, the news offers a welcome reprieve from the typical network chopping block that often befalls critically panned freshman shows.